3 Best Pellet Stoves Reviewed by Consumer Reports

Some areas like sunrooms and cabins without a proper heating system installed often make it very hard for those inside to have heated and cozy environment. In case you have such a space for living or sleeping in your home or office, where it is inevitable to live without a heating system, you have no option but to invest in a proper heating system that can work there. Thankfully, a pellet stove can do this job well, providing you with the kind of warmth that you need for the colder months.

A pellet stove looks similar to a wood stove but is different in a sense that it uses hardwood pellets inside for burning instead of wood pieces. The benefits of using these pellets instead of the other wood pieces is that they can burn more efficiently and also keep the place cleaner.

Another advantage is that unlike wood stoves where an owner or user has to consistently keep adding fuel to keep the fire going, the pellet stoves come with hoppers to fill the pellets once and then they automatically keep sending down these pellets to the firebox as and when needed.

The hoppers in most pellet stoves are big enough to let you fill them with the amount of pellets that is enough to keep the stove running for around 3 days before the are needed to be filled again.

Best Pellet Stoves Reviewed by Consumer Reports

#1 Castle Pellet Stoves Serenity

BIG HORN OUTDOORS Pizza Ovens Wood Pellet Pizza Oven Wood Fired Pizza Maker Portable Stainless Steel Pizza Grill
1,152 Reviews
BIG HORN OUTDOORS Pizza Ovens Wood Pellet Pizza Oven Wood Fired Pizza Maker Portable Stainless Steel Pizza Grill
  • 【Premium & Safe Stainless Steel】Outdoor Ovens pellet pizza oven is constructed with high-quality stainless steel. This sturdy and compact oven is safe for cooking all types of foods
  • 【Great Oven for Neapolitan Style Pizza】Our pellet pizza oven is ready to cook in 18 minutes. It reaches temperatures up to 860°F (460°C), cooking delicious pizza in 90 seconds or less, as well as roasting steaks, fish, lamp chops, burgers, salmon and vegetable dishes and so much more

Consumer Reports and Reviews

When we got our hands and used it for the first time, the stove took some time to start. It was enough to lead us to believe that the product is faulty of broken. However, it started burning and once it happened, we had enough warmth. I think this product does way more than it should considering its price tag. We use one bag of Douglas fire pellets that has around 40 lbs of pellets and it lasts around 75% longer than our last stove.

All in all, this stove is very easy to install and use. Comes with a tiny remote that we thought was too small to easily go lost and hence, places in our closet safely. One thing I like is the top mounted display of this stove. It not only looks aesthetic but also works great for me. If you want a booster warming, you can insulate the area around the stove and it will surely help make it more efficient in heating.

The only thing that I didn’t like was how the stove indicated that it has run out of fuel when there is still a good amount of pellet in the hopper, around 5-6 cups to be precise.

Otherwise, a very good product for bucks!

 Ratings: 4.8 
Lyle
Lyle
This one is surely a champion in the world of pellet stove markets. I agree this one has no such features that can lead one to call it as the smartest kid on the block, but that is fine because none of the other pellet stoves have it either. So, this one surely does enough in its price. Also, it is very easy to set up and use which is a plus for me. I also found it easy to clean and low maintenance for sure. Just don’t try to adjust the exhaust fan for higher altitude, this causes the view window to blur out.

Other than that, as far as the pellets are adjusted properly, they will burn clear and will also keep you warm enough. Mine initially came with a damaged remote, I contacted the customer services and they were kind enough to offer an exchange and the new one came within a day. Totally recommended!

 Ratings: 4.7 
Douglas
Douglas
The second ever stove that we got for our new home. Took us no more than 5 minutes to set it up and our HVAC company installed the vents. But, it won’t fire up because the exhaust fan was damaged. We called the tech support and they said they will ship new part in 2 days.

The new parts took no more than 10 minutes for replacement and the stove started running well. Extremely happy with what I got. Very happy with my stove. Despite the minor issue, the customer team dealt with it nicely. Surely, will be ordering another one for my master bedroom too.

 Ratings: 4.7 
Steven
Steven
After trying a lot of stoves and pellets, I took a leap of faith and ordered this one. AND IT SURELY WORKS! All thanks to the makers who have fulfilled all their claims and promises in this product. I initially had an issue because local installers were like… Ah, no we won’t install it!

However, one was kind enough and once it was installed, I just had to run it once and my entire space became perfectly toasty and cozy. Just make sure you are investing in good quality pellets and the installation guy knows his job. The rest, this stove will sort out itself!

 Ratings: 4.9 
James
James
Regretting my order!

I don’t know why but this stove won’t run for more than 15 minutes no matter what. The alarm shows that the hopper is empty and the burn pot aren’t right. I have checked and ensured multiple times. There is no issue with either of these. There is no way I can get in contact with the seller. Leaving this review here in hopes that I might be contacted! I would love to buy the right piece because it works best for those 15 minutes!

 Ratings: 1.5 
Manuel
Manuel

#2 US Stove Company US GW1949 Wiseway

BIG HORN OUTDOORS Pizza Ovens Wood Pellet Pizza Oven Wood Fired Pizza Maker Portable Stainless Steel Pizza Grill
1,152 Reviews
BIG HORN OUTDOORS Pizza Ovens Wood Pellet Pizza Oven Wood Fired Pizza Maker Portable Stainless Steel Pizza Grill
  • 【Premium & Safe Stainless Steel】Outdoor Ovens pellet pizza oven is constructed with high-quality stainless steel. This sturdy and compact oven is safe for cooking all types of foods
  • 【Great Oven for Neapolitan Style Pizza】Our pellet pizza oven is ready to cook in 18 minutes. It reaches temperatures up to 860°F (460°C), cooking delicious pizza in 90 seconds or less, as well as roasting steaks, fish, lamp chops, burgers, salmon and vegetable dishes and so much more

Consumer Reports and Reviews

Very compact stove that doesn’t take a lot of room but heat everything nicely. I love it for its radiating and dry heat giving property. If you know how to run a wood stove, you can easily operate this one too and you would love it once you get used to its working!

 Ratings: 4.9 
Thelma
Thelma
Love the simplicity of its working. I have seen so many negative reviews here that don’t make sense to me. If you aren’t sure how to ignite it, just refer to YouTube videos like I did. On highest I have taken it to 80 and it works amazing. I like how it gives off a very cozy and comfy radiating heat that doesn’t sting on skin. Clean burning is another thing I like about it. A great backup heating power that you surely need.

 Ratings: 4.7 
Patricia
Patricia
No offence to those leaving bad reviews, but you are simply not turning it on rightly. Once you understand its working, there is no way you’d want to buy another one. I got it at a discount and its super amazing. If you’re having issues with the smoke being put out, just use a higher pipe. It is an A1 product in all aspects.

 Ratings: 4.9 
Meaghan
Meaghan
Excellent and easy to use and clean item that we are blessed to have during power cuts.

 Ratings: 4.8 
Katie
Katie
A waste of money and nothing else. Don’t get it unless you are sure about having proper power supply all the time. The 40 lbs. bag of pallets won’t even last 14 hours while they advertised 36 hours. My 400 sq. ft., doesn’t even feel a little warm with this one. Totally disappointed. Don’t buy it.

 Ratings: 1.3 
Martha
Martha

#3 pelpro Pellet Stove

BIG HORN OUTDOORS Pizza Ovens Wood Pellet Pizza Oven Wood Fired Pizza Maker Portable Stainless Steel Pizza Grill
1,152 Reviews
BIG HORN OUTDOORS Pizza Ovens Wood Pellet Pizza Oven Wood Fired Pizza Maker Portable Stainless Steel Pizza Grill
  • 【Premium & Safe Stainless Steel】Outdoor Ovens pellet pizza oven is constructed with high-quality stainless steel. This sturdy and compact oven is safe for cooking all types of foods
  • 【Great Oven for Neapolitan Style Pizza】Our pellet pizza oven is ready to cook in 18 minutes. It reaches temperatures up to 860°F (460°C), cooking delicious pizza in 90 seconds or less, as well as roasting steaks, fish, lamp chops, burgers, salmon and vegetable dishes and so much more

Consumer Reports and Reviews

Amazing stove that offers excellent temperature control and an auto ignite feature. Turn on the knob and sit back while it does its job. I love how it can keep the entire house equally warm. The big hopper can easily be filled with around 3 bags of pallets and they can last a week if you use it nicely.

Will recommend for sure!

 Ratings: 4.8 
Keri
Keri
Been using it for around 14 days now. Perfect in all honesty. Thermostats works well and the heating is amazing too. Will come back with more details once I’ve used it enough.

 Ratings: 4.9 
Cecilia
Cecilia
Excellent heating capability. I have a two story house on 3700 sq. ft. and I didn’t have to turn on the furnace even for once this year. We keep it on level 7 and it keeps the entire home warm. We don’t turn it off when we are out, rather keep it at 3 to enjoy the same cozy feeling once we are back. Great investment that saves us a lot of propane.

 Ratings: 4.9 
Christina
Christina
Big hopper. Easy to use and produces no ash when premium pine pellet was used. Amazing!

 Ratings: 4.7 
Theresa
Theresa
I have had it for around 3 years. Every other day, a new part of it needs to be replaced. Temperature controller, motherboard, hopper and vacuum switches and what not had to be replaced, some of these even twice. I am done! Looking for a new one now.

They had good tech service but they should focus on their parts quality. Annoying! The heat output is excellent when it is working well.

 Ratings: 1.2 
Dan
Dan

Leave a Comment